RESEARCH IN CONVERSATION
Philosophy does not end with publication; her arguments invite responses, criticisms, and alternative interpretations — often from people working in quite different disciplines. This is the nature of effective interdisciplinary engagement, in which philosophical thinking brings her distinctive critical perspective into conversation with other disciplines, helping to examine underlying assumptions, sharpen arguments, and encourage the wider incorporation of philosophical inquiry into their practices.
The following examples illustrate how my research has been engaged in both public and specialist discourse, and debated through broader scholarly discourse. Some explore the implications of my arguments in different contexts, while others reflect sustained philosophical disagreements over their interpretation and application in practice. Where possible, I have included links to the original material so that readers can explore these discussions for themselves.
SCHOLARLY ENGAGEMENT
In this chapter, Don Kulick offers a thoughtful and provocative examination of the longstanding debate surrounding disability, sexuality, and sexual rights. Drawing upon historical examples and contemporary philosophical arguments, he challenges the tendency for academic discussions to become preoccupied with questions of rights and terminology rather than the practical needs of disabled people.
My proposed welfare-funded Sex Doula Programme features in Kulick's discussion as an example of how debates over terminology can distract from disabled people's needs. However, his interpretation perhaps gives insufficient weight to the central purpose of my original Journal of Medical Ethics article: to establish a comprehensive, publicly funded service addressing sexual exclusion. The distinction between sex doulas and conventional sexual surrogates featuring in my original and subsequent materials is critical precisely because the programme extends beyond sexual encounters to provide broader practical support — much like the Danish model Kulick advocates. Nevertheless, I welcome Kulick's incorporation of my work into this wider debate, and value his contribution to advancing discussion of disabled people's sexual citizenship.
Don Kulick (2025) — ‘Rights vs. Wrong: Debates About Sex and Disability’, in Clashing Vulnerabilities, Disability and Conflict, Chapter 4, pp. 67–83. Routledge.
The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry ‘Sex and Sexuality’ cites my 2019 paper on the welfare-funded Sex Doula Programme in its examination of positive sexual rights and the moral obligations arising from sexual exclusion.
Raja Halwani (2023) — ‘Sex and Sexuality’, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, §2.2, ‘Sex and Morality’.
My work on the proposed welfare-funded Sex Doula Programme has prompted an extended philosophical exchange with Ezio Di Nucci, beginning with my 2019 response to his earlier criticism of positive sexual rights. Published across the Journal of Medical Ethics, its associated blog, and Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics, the debate examines the relationship between positive and negative sexual rights, the obligations of welfare states, and the practical challenges of advancing disabled people's sexual citizenship.
Although Di Nucci and I share a profound commitment to improving the sexual lives of disabled people, our philosophical debate over the matter has developed beyond the original ‘sexual rights puzzle’. Most notably, my subsequent work with Ivars Neiders challenges the suggestion that practical interventions should await a more comprehensive philosophical reckoning with the place of sexuality in society.
Ezio Di Nucci (2019–2023) — A Debate on Sexual Rights and Disability
In this chapter, John Danaher draws upon my work on the proposed welfare-funded Sex Doula Programme, including my subsequent collaboration with Ivars Neiders, to examine the possibility of recognising positive sexual rights without compromising individual autonomy. He discusses our argument that the state may have an obligation to fund access to sexual services for disabled people without imposing any corresponding obligation upon individuals to provide those services. Danaher also considers potential objections to our proposal, including concerns that public funding might create indirect pressures upon people to enter sex work.
John Danaher (2022) — The Routledge Handbook of Philosophy of Sex and Sexuality, Chapter 4, pp. 50–64.
In this article, John Danaher develops a broader philosophical defence of sexual inclusion as a matter of distributive justice, drawing upon existing debates concerning the sexual exclusion of disabled people, including my 2019 work. He considers my criticism of Ezio Di Nucci's ‘sexual rights puzzle’ in examining the possible tensions between positive sexual rights and individual autonomy, while arguing that unjust sexual exclusion can warrant positive obligations upon society without establishing an entitlement to sexual access to another person.
John Danaher (2020) — Social Theory and Practice, 46(3), pp. 467–496.
PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT
Drawing upon an interview with Tim Ventura, this AltSci article explores my work on the philosophical challenges of extraterrestrial first contact, including the assumptions underlying game-theoretical approaches to encounters with alien intelligence. The discussion considers the limitations of applying familiar terrestrial frameworks to radically unfamiliar circumstances and the importance of developing principles for responsible engagement before contact occurs.
AltSci (2025) — ‘The Axioms of First Contact with Extraterrestrials’, 2 May 2025.
John I. Davies' discussion of my paper 'An Assay on the Hobbesian Trap and Axioms of First Contact' in Principium, the magazine of the Initiative for Interstellar Studies, examines my proposed axioms of first contact in relation to familiar problems of strategic uncertainty, deterrence, and communication with extraterrestrial intelligence.
Davies' article, ‘Don't Shoot First!’, is available here.
Principium, Issue 43 (November 2023)
In this article for Universe Today, subsequently republished by Phys.org, astrophysicist and established science writer Brian Koberlein discusses my critique of applying Hobbesian reasoning to extraterrestrial first contact, exploring how the potential benefits of cooperation and the physical circumstances we might share challenge the assumption that pre-emptive aggression would be a rational response.
20-21 September, 2023
This article in SFcrowsnest discusses my interview with Tim Ventura, exploring the challenges of communication, reasoning, and cultural interpretation in the event of extraterrestrial first contact, and how misunderstandings and uncertainty might give rise to a Hobbesian Trap.
19th March, 2023.